Hello! Project Members Ranking ~2015 edition~
Moderators: testacles_4, Shoujo Q, momoirosaya
- momoirosaya
- つんく♂
- Posts: 5148
- Joined: Thu Feb 11, 2010 8:21 pm
Re: Hello! Project Members Ranking ~2015 edition~
New girls are more towards the bottom because I don't know enough about them to rank them properly. Chisaki is cute but I feel like I know NOTHING about her. I can't even get a feel for her personality, even though I already have for Uta and Mai.
This time I avoided hitting the tie button to have a clear ranking. It was hard because I'll like 2 equally members for different things. It's funny though because with Maasa and Chinami, there was a time when I really liked them.
--LOVE--
1. Ikuta Erina (--)
2. Ishida Ayumi (+1)
3. Tsugunaga Momoko (+2)
4. Kudou Haruka (+7)
5. Wada Ayaka (+1)
6. Shimizu Saki (+13)
7. Fukuda Kanon (+4)
8. Nakajima Saki (-2)
9. Miyamoto Karin (+5)
--Really Like--
10. Sayashi Riho (-1)
11. Tamura Meimi (+16)
12. Yajima Maimi (+6)
13. Fukumura Mizuki (-10)
14. Oda Sakura (--)
--New Girls I Love-
15. Sasaki Rikako (NEW)
16. Inaba Manaka (NEW)
17. Shimamura Uta (NEW)
--Like--
18. Okai Chisato (-7)
19. Kanazawa Tomoko (-5)
20. Murota Mizuki (NEW)
21. Suzuki Airi (7)
22. Satou Masaki (-12)
23. Uemura Akari (--)
24. Nakanishi Kana (-1)
25. Hagiwara Mai (-6)
26. Takeuchi Akari (-3)
27. Ozeki Mai (NEW)
28. Iikubo Haruna (-22)
29. Miyazaki Yuka (-2)
30. Natsuyaki Miyabi (+2)
31. Sugaya Risako (+2)
32. Suzuki Kanon (-13)
33. Takagi Sayuki (-10)
34. Nonaka Miki (NEW)
35. Makino Maria (NEW)
36. Kumai Yurina (-9)
37. Katsuta Rina (-18)
--No Opinion--
38. Ogata Haruna (NEW)
39. Yamaki Risa (NEW)
40. Haga Akane (NEW)
---Not interested in---
41. Tokunaga Chinami (-8)
42. Aikawa Maho (NEW)
43. Sudou Maasa (-9)
--Mystery Girl--
44. Morito Chisaki (NEW)
This time I avoided hitting the tie button to have a clear ranking. It was hard because I'll like 2 equally members for different things. It's funny though because with Maasa and Chinami, there was a time when I really liked them.
--LOVE--
1. Ikuta Erina (--)
2. Ishida Ayumi (+1)
3. Tsugunaga Momoko (+2)
4. Kudou Haruka (+7)
5. Wada Ayaka (+1)
6. Shimizu Saki (+13)
7. Fukuda Kanon (+4)
8. Nakajima Saki (-2)
9. Miyamoto Karin (+5)
--Really Like--
10. Sayashi Riho (-1)
11. Tamura Meimi (+16)
12. Yajima Maimi (+6)
13. Fukumura Mizuki (-10)
14. Oda Sakura (--)
--New Girls I Love-
15. Sasaki Rikako (NEW)
16. Inaba Manaka (NEW)
17. Shimamura Uta (NEW)
--Like--
18. Okai Chisato (-7)
19. Kanazawa Tomoko (-5)
20. Murota Mizuki (NEW)
21. Suzuki Airi (7)
22. Satou Masaki (-12)
23. Uemura Akari (--)
24. Nakanishi Kana (-1)
25. Hagiwara Mai (-6)
26. Takeuchi Akari (-3)
27. Ozeki Mai (NEW)
28. Iikubo Haruna (-22)
29. Miyazaki Yuka (-2)
30. Natsuyaki Miyabi (+2)
31. Sugaya Risako (+2)
32. Suzuki Kanon (-13)
33. Takagi Sayuki (-10)
34. Nonaka Miki (NEW)
35. Makino Maria (NEW)
36. Kumai Yurina (-9)
37. Katsuta Rina (-18)
--No Opinion--
38. Ogata Haruna (NEW)
39. Yamaki Risa (NEW)
40. Haga Akane (NEW)
---Not interested in---
41. Tokunaga Chinami (-8)
42. Aikawa Maho (NEW)
43. Sudou Maasa (-9)
--Mystery Girl--
44. Morito Chisaki (NEW)
rikako♡eripon♡airi
Re: Hello! Project Members Ranking ~2015 edition~
My results:
1位 Mizuki Fukumura 132p
2位 Mai Hagiwara 129p
3位 Maimi Yajima 126p
4位 Rikako Sasaki 123p
5位 Sakura Oda 120p
6位 Airi Suzuki 117p
7位 Saki Nakajima 114p
8位 Mizuki Murota 111p
9位 Meimi Tamura 108p
10位 Ayumi Ishida 105p
11位 Uta Shimamura 102p
12位 Haruka Kudo 99p
13位 Ayaka Wada 96p
14位 Maria Makino 93p
15位 Akari Uemura 90p
16位 Karin Miyamoto 87p
17位 Chisato Okai 84p
18位 Sayuki Takagi 81p
19位 Akari Takeuchi 78p
20位 Erina Ikuta 75p
21位 Risako Sugaya 72p
22位 Yurina Kumai 69p
23位 Riho Sayashi 66p
24位 Momoko Tsugunaga 63p
25位 Kanon Suzuki 60p
26位 Yuka Miyazaki 57p
27位 Akane Haga 54p
28位 Haruna Iikubo 51p
29位 Aika Mitsui 48p
30位 Miyabi Natsuyaki 45p
31位 Masaki Sato 42p
32位 Haruna Ogata 39p
33位 Maasa Sudou 36p
34位 Maho Aikawa 33p
35位 Miki Nonaka 30p
36位 Kanon Fukuda 27p
37位 Saki Shimizu 24p
38位 Chinami Tokunaga 21p
39位 Tomoko Kanazawa 18p
40位 Chisaki Morito 15p
41位 Risa Yamaki 12p
42位 Mai Ozeki 9p
43位 Kana Nakanishi 6p
44位 Manaka Inaba 3p
45位 Rina Katsuta 0p
I couldn't find the kana version of 森戸知沙希's name to save my life, so there she sits whoever she is. All the Country Girls' members's names are subject to wrongness too since my Japanese has gotten super rusty.
I need more time to get to know the 12th gen MM girls and Country Girls because I had no clue who was who for most of the voting.
EDIT: Fuck, the board undid all the formatting. :( Argh, fixed it to not run together anymore.
EDIT 2: And kanji name fixed thanks to Saya. Thanks, Saya!
1位 Mizuki Fukumura 132p
2位 Mai Hagiwara 129p
3位 Maimi Yajima 126p
4位 Rikako Sasaki 123p
5位 Sakura Oda 120p
6位 Airi Suzuki 117p
7位 Saki Nakajima 114p
8位 Mizuki Murota 111p
9位 Meimi Tamura 108p
10位 Ayumi Ishida 105p
11位 Uta Shimamura 102p
12位 Haruka Kudo 99p
13位 Ayaka Wada 96p
14位 Maria Makino 93p
15位 Akari Uemura 90p
16位 Karin Miyamoto 87p
17位 Chisato Okai 84p
18位 Sayuki Takagi 81p
19位 Akari Takeuchi 78p
20位 Erina Ikuta 75p
21位 Risako Sugaya 72p
22位 Yurina Kumai 69p
23位 Riho Sayashi 66p
24位 Momoko Tsugunaga 63p
25位 Kanon Suzuki 60p
26位 Yuka Miyazaki 57p
27位 Akane Haga 54p
28位 Haruna Iikubo 51p
29位 Aika Mitsui 48p
30位 Miyabi Natsuyaki 45p
31位 Masaki Sato 42p
32位 Haruna Ogata 39p
33位 Maasa Sudou 36p
34位 Maho Aikawa 33p
35位 Miki Nonaka 30p
36位 Kanon Fukuda 27p
37位 Saki Shimizu 24p
38位 Chinami Tokunaga 21p
39位 Tomoko Kanazawa 18p
40位 Chisaki Morito 15p
41位 Risa Yamaki 12p
42位 Mai Ozeki 9p
43位 Kana Nakanishi 6p
44位 Manaka Inaba 3p
45位 Rina Katsuta 0p
I couldn't find the kana version of 森戸知沙希's name to save my life, so there she sits whoever she is. All the Country Girls' members's names are subject to wrongness too since my Japanese has gotten super rusty.
I need more time to get to know the 12th gen MM girls and Country Girls because I had no clue who was who for most of the voting.
EDIT: Fuck, the board undid all the formatting. :( Argh, fixed it to not run together anymore.
EDIT 2: And kanji name fixed thanks to Saya. Thanks, Saya!
Last edited by showraniy on Sat Feb 07, 2015 2:59 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- momoirosaya
- つんく♂
- Posts: 5148
- Joined: Thu Feb 11, 2010 8:21 pm
Re: Hello! Project Members Ranking ~2015 edition~
Sasaki Rikako placed shockingly high on my list. I don't even know who she is. Her picture was just so pretty that I kept clicking on it haha.
I'm surprised so much by my list. It just shows how little I keep up with HP because it seems to be organized by sheer familiarity.
1位 鈴木愛理 132p Suzuki airi
2位 夏焼雅 129p miyabi
3位 矢島舞美 126p maimi
4位 福田花音 123p fukuda kanon
5位 和田彩花 120p ayacho
6位 清水佐紀 117p shimizu saki
7位 工藤遥 114p kudo
8位 生田衣梨奈 111p ikuta
9位 鞘師里保 108p rihoho
10位 小田さくら 105p oda
11位 佐々木莉佳子 102p pretty girl that just joined angerme
12位 譜久村聖 99p fukumura
13位 鈴木香音 96p Suzuki
14位 菅谷梨沙子 93p risako
15位 飯窪春菜 90p iikubo
16位 佐藤優樹 87p sato
17位 4須藤茉麻 84p masaa
18位 牧野真莉愛 81p chinami
19位 (new girls start here)
Edit: no this can't be right. I didn't tie anyone and I'm doing it on my phone so maybe I mixed a few girls up. Will redo later.
I'm surprised so much by my list. It just shows how little I keep up with HP because it seems to be organized by sheer familiarity.
1位 鈴木愛理 132p Suzuki airi
2位 夏焼雅 129p miyabi
3位 矢島舞美 126p maimi
4位 福田花音 123p fukuda kanon
5位 和田彩花 120p ayacho
6位 清水佐紀 117p shimizu saki
7位 工藤遥 114p kudo
8位 生田衣梨奈 111p ikuta
9位 鞘師里保 108p rihoho
10位 小田さくら 105p oda
11位 佐々木莉佳子 102p pretty girl that just joined angerme
12位 譜久村聖 99p fukumura
13位 鈴木香音 96p Suzuki
14位 菅谷梨沙子 93p risako
15位 飯窪春菜 90p iikubo
16位 佐藤優樹 87p sato
17位 4須藤茉麻 84p masaa
18位 牧野真莉愛 81p chinami
19位 (new girls start here)
Edit: no this can't be right. I didn't tie anyone and I'm doing it on my phone so maybe I mixed a few girls up. Will redo later.
Last edited by eri on Tue Feb 10, 2015 9:46 am, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Hello! Project Members Ranking ~2015 edition~
Now that I know CG more, and BK is no longer in I did it again:
01. Sayashi Riho
02. Kudou Haruka
03. Ishida Ayumi
04. Okai Chisato
04. Takeuchi Akari
06. Fukumura Mizuki
06. Nakajima Saki
08. Nakanishi Kana
09. Ogata Haruna
10. Oda Sakura
11. Shimamura Uta
12. Iikubo Haruna
13. Uemura Akari
14. Miyamoto Karin
15. Haga Akane
16. Makino Maria
17. Tamura Meimi
18. Nonaka Miki
19. Inaba Manaka
20. Murota Mizuki
21. Satou Masaki
22. Kanazawa Tomoko
23. Hamaura Ayano
24. Ikuta Erina
25. Yamaki Risa
26. Wada Sakurako
27. Suzuki Kanon
28. Sasaki Rikako
29. Hirose Ayaka
30. Taguchi Natsumi
31. Miyazaki Yuka
31. Ozeki Mai
33. Katsuta Rina
34. Hagiwara Mai
35. Aikawa Maho
36. Morito Chisaki
37. Inoue Rei
38. Fujii Rio
39. Yajima Maimi
39. Suzuki Airi
39. Wada Ayaka
42. Ogawa Rena
43. Nomura Minami
44. Fukuda Kanon
44. Takagi Sayuki
44. Tsugunaga Momoko
44. Mitsui Aika
01. Sayashi Riho
02. Kudou Haruka
03. Ishida Ayumi
04. Okai Chisato
04. Takeuchi Akari
06. Fukumura Mizuki
06. Nakajima Saki
08. Nakanishi Kana
09. Ogata Haruna
10. Oda Sakura
11. Shimamura Uta
12. Iikubo Haruna
13. Uemura Akari
14. Miyamoto Karin
15. Haga Akane
16. Makino Maria
17. Tamura Meimi
18. Nonaka Miki
19. Inaba Manaka
20. Murota Mizuki
21. Satou Masaki
22. Kanazawa Tomoko
23. Hamaura Ayano
24. Ikuta Erina
25. Yamaki Risa
26. Wada Sakurako
27. Suzuki Kanon
28. Sasaki Rikako
29. Hirose Ayaka
30. Taguchi Natsumi
31. Miyazaki Yuka
31. Ozeki Mai
33. Katsuta Rina
34. Hagiwara Mai
35. Aikawa Maho
36. Morito Chisaki
37. Inoue Rei
38. Fujii Rio
39. Yajima Maimi
39. Suzuki Airi
39. Wada Ayaka
42. Ogawa Rena
43. Nomura Minami
44. Fukuda Kanon
44. Takagi Sayuki
44. Tsugunaga Momoko
44. Mitsui Aika
Last edited by MejraThea on Tue Mar 17, 2015 5:39 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Hello! Project Members Ranking ~2015 edition~
I thought I'd take it again now that Berryz are out, but I thought I'd just include the top ten.
1. Ishida Ayumi
2. Uemura Akari
3. Satou Masaki
4. Shimamura Uta
5. Katsuta Rina
6. Kanazawa Tomoko
7. Fukumura Mizuki
8. Suzuki Kanon
9. Kudou Haruka
10. Takeuchi Akari
I'm kind of suprised how high Maachan and Bakuwara scored, but I guess recently taken a greater liking to Maachan and have started to like how Bakuwara looks consistently unimpressed but still performs alright.
Most of the girls on the bottom were from Kobushi Factory, simply because I don't know much about them yet.
1. Ishida Ayumi
2. Uemura Akari
3. Satou Masaki
4. Shimamura Uta
5. Katsuta Rina
6. Kanazawa Tomoko
7. Fukumura Mizuki
8. Suzuki Kanon
9. Kudou Haruka
10. Takeuchi Akari
I'm kind of suprised how high Maachan and Bakuwara scored, but I guess recently taken a greater liking to Maachan and have started to like how Bakuwara looks consistently unimpressed but still performs alright.
Most of the girls on the bottom were from Kobushi Factory, simply because I don't know much about them yet.
Re: Hello! Project Members Ranking ~2015 edition~
I refuse to take this ever again ;_;
♥ Kaori • Risako ♥
♥ Sakura • Kananan • Sayuki ♥
- TicTacAnyone
- ANGERME
- Posts: 2519
- Joined: Mon Jan 13, 2014 4:38 am
Re: Hello! Project Members Ranking ~2015 edition~
Top 15:
1. Suzuki Airi
2. Sato Masaki
3. Oda Sakura
4. Nonka Miki
5. Iikubo Haruna
6. Shimamura Uta
7. Ishida Ayumi
8. Fukumura Mizuki
9. Nakajima Saki
10. Miyamoto Karin
11. Kanazawa Tomoko
12. Murota Mizuki
13. Tsugunaga Momoko
14. Suzuki Kanon
15. Oogata Haruna
Wellllll... That changed a lot....
1. Suzuki Airi
2. Sato Masaki
3. Oda Sakura
4. Nonka Miki
5. Iikubo Haruna
6. Shimamura Uta
7. Ishida Ayumi
8. Fukumura Mizuki
9. Nakajima Saki
10. Miyamoto Karin
11. Kanazawa Tomoko
12. Murota Mizuki
13. Tsugunaga Momoko
14. Suzuki Kanon
15. Oogata Haruna
Wellllll... That changed a lot....
Re: Hello! Project Members Ranking ~2015 edition~
New Ranking
Top 10
1. Suzuki Kanon
2. Oda Sakura
3. Suzuki Airi
4. Sayashi Riho + Kudo Haruka
6. Ozeki Mai
7. Fukumura Mizuki
8. Kanazawa Tomoko + Uemuera Akari
10. Fukuda Kanon + Tamura Meimi
12-20
12. Makino Maria
13. Ogata Haruna
14. Chisaki
15. Angerme's Mizuki + Rikako
17. Miki
18. Utachan
19. Okai Chisato
20. Haga Akane
21-30
21. Ishida Ayumi
22. Natsumi
23. Manaka
24. Kananan
25. Karin
26. Risa
27. Maimi
28. Maho
29. Sayuki
30. Ayano
31-40
31. Wada
32. Momoko
33. some girl from kobushi apparently
34. Rina
35. Mai
36-40. Kobushi girls i still don't know
41-46
41. Yuka
42. Iikubo
43. Erina
44. Takeuchi
45. Nakajima
46.Masaki
Top 10
1. Suzuki Kanon
2. Oda Sakura
3. Suzuki Airi
4. Sayashi Riho + Kudo Haruka
6. Ozeki Mai
7. Fukumura Mizuki
8. Kanazawa Tomoko + Uemuera Akari
10. Fukuda Kanon + Tamura Meimi
12-20
12. Makino Maria
13. Ogata Haruna
14. Chisaki
15. Angerme's Mizuki + Rikako
17. Miki
18. Utachan
19. Okai Chisato
20. Haga Akane
21-30
21. Ishida Ayumi
22. Natsumi
23. Manaka
24. Kananan
25. Karin
26. Risa
27. Maimi
28. Maho
29. Sayuki
30. Ayano
31-40
31. Wada
32. Momoko
33. some girl from kobushi apparently
34. Rina
35. Mai
36-40. Kobushi girls i still don't know
41-46
41. Yuka
42. Iikubo
43. Erina
44. Takeuchi
45. Nakajima
46.Masaki
<p style="text-align:center;">我最爱你。你是我的太阳。
Re: Hello! Project Members Ranking ~2015 edition~
Decided to do this again since there's new members and I was curious to see where people went now that Berryz isn't there.
Of course newbies are more near the bottom. But Country Girls are fast approaching the rankings of older H!P members. It took a lot of willpower not to let my emotions get the best of me and make them all take the top. Iikubo keeps falling. Opps.
Of course newbies are more near the bottom. But Country Girls are fast approaching the rankings of older H!P members. It took a lot of willpower not to let my emotions get the best of me and make them all take the top. Iikubo keeps falling. Opps.
- 羽賀小田さくら - Oda Sakura
- 鈴木 愛理 - Suzuki Airi
- 田村 芽実 - Tamura Meimi
- 鈴木 香音 - Suzuki Kanon
- 福田 花音 - Fukuda Kanon
- 島村嬉唄 - Shimamura Uta
- 岡井 千聖 - Okai Chisato
- 佐々木莉佳子 - Sasaki Rikako
- 矢島 舞美 -Yajima Maimi
- 石田亜佑美 - Ishida Ayumi
- 工藤 遥 - Kudo Haruka
- 高木 紗友希 -Takagi Sayuki
- 宮本 佳林 - Miyamoto Karin
- 中西 香菜 - Nakanishi Kana
- 金澤 朋子 -Kanazawa Tomoko
- 鞘師 里保 - Sayashi Riho
- 竹内 朱莉 -Takeuchi Akari
- 和田 彩花 - Wada Ayaka
- 稲場愛香 - Inaba Manaka
- 佐藤 優樹 - Sato Masaki
- 室田瑞希 - Murota Mizuki
- 小関舞 - Ozeki Mai
- 嗣永 桃子 - Tsugunaga Momoko
- 藤井梨央 - Fujii Rio
- 広瀬彩海 - Hirose Ayaka
- 飯窪 春菜 - Iikubo Haruna
- 山木梨沙 - Yamaki Risa
- 譜久村 聖 - Fukumura Mizuki
- 野中美希 - Nonaka Miki
- 浜浦彩乃 - Hamaura Ayano
- 森戸知沙希 - Morito Chisaki
- 宮崎 由加 - Miyazaki Yuka
- 植村 あかり - Uemura Akari
- 中島 早貴 - Nakajima Saki
- 生田衣梨奈 - Ikuta Erina
- 尾形春水 - Ogata Haruna
- 勝田 里奈 - Katsuta Rina
- 朱音 - Haga Akane
- 牧野真莉愛 - Makino Maria
- 田口夏実 - Taguchi Natsumi
- 野村みな美 - Nomura Minami
- 井上玲音 - Inoue Rei
- 萩原 舞 - Hagiwara Mai
- 小川麗奈 - Ogawa Rena
- 和田桜子 - Wada Sakurako
- 相川茉穂 - Aikawa Maho
This is a place where a signature goes. Enjoy some Airi instead.
- freezingkiss
- ANGERME
- Posts: 1523
- Joined: Sun Sep 17, 2006 8:00 pm
Re: Hello! Project Members Ranking ~2015 edition~
It's so difficult to care now Maasa is gone but maybe
1. All of C-ute
2. Everyone else
1. All of C-ute
2. Everyone else
新垣里沙 ♥ 須藤茉麻 ♥中島早貴 ♥ 譜久村聖 ♥All of C-ute ♥All of Berryz♥
- WonderBuono
- ANGERME
- Posts: 1519
- Joined: Sun Mar 15, 2015 8:03 am
Re: Hello! Project Members Ranking ~2015 edition~
I had a grand Hello Pro ranking on my H!P Wiki profile that I did myself, but there's just so many people it was hard to keep up with. So I used the sorter for this one, and tried to answer honestly, but sometimes its hard to pick between two members who are good at totally different things.
Actually, I took it twice because the first time Chisato ended up waaaaayyyy at the bottom, like below some Kobushi Factory members (whom I was trying to keep near the bottom since I don't know much about them). I dislike her, but not THAT much. :P So, my answers ended up being pretty different the second time around I think. Here they are:
1. Suzuki Airi
1. Tsugunaga Momoko
(I'm biased... Buono! members will always be number 1 for me!)
3. Wada Ayaka
4. Iikubo Haruna
5. Sayashi Riho
6. Nonaka Miki
7. Ishida Ayumi
8. Takagi Sayuki
9. Suzuki Kanon (she really should be above Ayumi...)
10. Nakanishi Kana
11. Takeuchi Akari
12. Inaba Manaka
13. Oda Sakura
14. Hagiwara Mai
15. Yajima Maimi
16. Nakajima Saki
17. Sasaki Rikako
18. Fukumura Mizuki
19. Yamaki Risa
20. Sato Masaki
21. Shimamura Uta
22. Makino Maria
23. Morito Chisaki
24. Murota Mizuki
25. Katsuta Rina
26. Ozeki Mai
27. Mitsui Aika (she would be higher if she weren't on hiatus)
28. Kanazawa Tomoko
29. Uemura Akari
30. Tamura Meimi
31. Miyamoto Karin
32. Fukuda Kanon
33. Kudo Haruka
34. Okai Chisato
35. Hamaura Ayano
36. Miyazaki Yuka
37. Hirose Ayaka
38. Ogata Haruna
39. Aikawa Maho
40. Haga Akane
41. Ikuta Erina
42. Fujii Rio
42. Nomura Minami
42. Ogawa Rena
42. Taguchi Natsumi
42. Wada Sakurako
43. Inoue Rei
Actually, I took it twice because the first time Chisato ended up waaaaayyyy at the bottom, like below some Kobushi Factory members (whom I was trying to keep near the bottom since I don't know much about them). I dislike her, but not THAT much. :P So, my answers ended up being pretty different the second time around I think. Here they are:
1. Suzuki Airi
1. Tsugunaga Momoko
(I'm biased... Buono! members will always be number 1 for me!)
3. Wada Ayaka
4. Iikubo Haruna
5. Sayashi Riho
6. Nonaka Miki
7. Ishida Ayumi
8. Takagi Sayuki
9. Suzuki Kanon (she really should be above Ayumi...)
10. Nakanishi Kana
11. Takeuchi Akari
12. Inaba Manaka
13. Oda Sakura
14. Hagiwara Mai
15. Yajima Maimi
16. Nakajima Saki
17. Sasaki Rikako
18. Fukumura Mizuki
19. Yamaki Risa
20. Sato Masaki
21. Shimamura Uta
22. Makino Maria
23. Morito Chisaki
24. Murota Mizuki
25. Katsuta Rina
26. Ozeki Mai
27. Mitsui Aika (she would be higher if she weren't on hiatus)
28. Kanazawa Tomoko
29. Uemura Akari
30. Tamura Meimi
31. Miyamoto Karin
32. Fukuda Kanon
33. Kudo Haruka
34. Okai Chisato
35. Hamaura Ayano
36. Miyazaki Yuka
37. Hirose Ayaka
38. Ogata Haruna
39. Aikawa Maho
40. Haga Akane
41. Ikuta Erina
42. Fujii Rio
42. Nomura Minami
42. Ogawa Rena
42. Taguchi Natsumi
42. Wada Sakurako
43. Inoue Rei
<p style="text-align:right;">MORNING MUSUME ◆ SUZUKI AIRI ◆ JUICE=JUICE ◆ TWICE ◆ BLACKPINK ◆ ITZY◆ NIZIU
Re: Hello! Project Members Ranking ~2015 edition~
1 - Fukumura Mizuki
2 - Sayashi Riho
3 - Sato Masaki
4 - Aikawa Maho
5 - Ishida Ayumi
6 - Oda Sakura
7 - Katsuta Rina
8 - Ozeki Mai
9 - Ikuta Erina
10 - Yamaki Risa
Too lazy for the others. Bottom three with Okai Chisato, Miyamoto Karin and Hamaura Ayano.
2 - Sayashi Riho
3 - Sato Masaki
4 - Aikawa Maho
5 - Ishida Ayumi
6 - Oda Sakura
7 - Katsuta Rina
8 - Ozeki Mai
9 - Ikuta Erina
10 - Yamaki Risa
Too lazy for the others. Bottom three with Okai Chisato, Miyamoto Karin and Hamaura Ayano.
[11:13:35 PM] Liam: DO NOT LET JAPANESE IDOLS GET IN THE WAY OF THE *AMERICAN* DREAM
- Solarblade
- ANGERME
- Posts: 1507
- Joined: Wed May 02, 2012 6:06 pm
Re: Hello! Project Members Ranking ~2015 edition~
So since every group has released a single (sans Tsubaki) I wanna talk about them after their debut single, starting with...
===Momusu===
1. Maria Makino - After seeing just the Another ver. of "Seishun Kozou ga Naiteiru", I figured she'd be the visual ace of the new generation. She seems the most polished and watching their dance shots, she looks like she has the most snap to her dancing which is a plus from being a KSS. Sadly, I really couldn't figure where she stands vocally amongst the other members.
2. Akane Haga - Maybe it's just me, but when I watch Akanechin...she exudes this serious demeanor and looks a lot more mature than maybe she knows herself. Like the other generation mates, vocally from the new single...they're all quite invisible and that's a shame.
3. Haruna Ogata - I blame "Ima Koko Kara" for this because I noticed Ogata quite a lot in that PV for some reason. Still, not sure where she'll fit, but she's quite nice to look at.
4. Miki Nonoka - Besides the multitude times I heard her speak English, if she didn't have that, I probably wouldn't have keyed in on her because I don't recall paying attention to her at all in any of the 4 PVs we got.
<b>OVERALL: </b>Visually, they were sticking out and I quickly recognized who was who...unfortunately, their debut single did nothing in terms of showing their vocal capabilities (since all they had were duet lines). 2/5
===ANGERME===
1. Mizuki Murota - Already in their debut single, Murotan is the vocal ace of the new generation. She's done quite a lot to get there and impressed many too. There's just something about her that works in the group and she honestly looks happy to perform with the group, so she's still one of my favorites!
2. Rikako Sasaki - I was surprised that Rikako and Maho got nothing in terms of lines in their debut single (whereas Murotan got two significant lines their debut). Howerver, Rikako is the visual ace it seems due to her popularity and because "Taikibansei" had her dead in the middle quite a lot. In time I bet she'll become one of the mains, but I think it's best left to Mizuki at the moment.
3. Maho Aikawa - I mean it wasn't very long for Aiai to debut and I was curious to how she sounded, but that didn't happen and she was a bit off in wherever she was (a little like Kanana when she started). I hope this awkward phase goes away because other than that, she's still kind of an unknown to me.
OVERALL: A little better than Momusu with showing off their members and having Murotan be the front vocals of the 3rd generation and Rikako as the visual representation...though where would Maho be then? lol. 3/5
===Country Girls===
1. Mai Ozeki - She is definitely my favorite of the group as of their first single. Something boyish about her is really pulling me in as well as her having my favorite color, blue. I do like her kind of raspy/husky voice to kind of counteract all the overall cuteness that the rest of the group has as well...she's just so charming!
2, Uta Shimomura - Which also is the same story as Utachan. She's REALLY charming as well and the fact that she's being pushed as the ace is quite surprising but effective, she's just a doll in "Itooshikutte Gomen ne".
3. Risa Yamaki - Even though she isn't the oldest thanks to Momoko, Yamakki is the odd member of the group I feel like. She's a lot more poised and mature and doesn't scream young girl which makes sense there...her voice is nice, a bit different against the other 5 members but refreshing I say.
4. Manaka Inaba - Besides the Dance Club stuff, Manakan's voice doesn't really do much for me (though that "Say! Hello!" line she has is pretty epic otherwise). Right now, she's kind of being shadowed by the rest of the group, so hopefully she catches up with me with adding her dance skills to the group.
5. Chisaki Morito - I really don't know why, but Chisaki just goes over my head and yet she gets more solo lines than Yamaki and Inaba :0 Made worse by the fact that Ozeki and Shimomura (and even Momoko) have such big charm points to them currently...I wanna see if she'll make a change by the end of the year.
OVERALL: Unlike Momusu and ANGERME, all the members got quite a lot of spotlight and solos and while they're on the rough side vocal-wise, their presence is quite worth it and Momoko doesn't get in the way 4/5
===Kobushi Factory===
1. Rio Fujii - With so much personality right from day 1, Rio has always been the underdog KSS for me and I'm so happy she was chosen as sub-leader of the group. While she isn't a vocal lead like Rei, Ayaka, and Minami...she's a great dancer so I'm definitely keeping my eye out for her.
2. Rei Inoue - When they first announced the group, I had no idea what to expect from Reirei but she's got some power in her voice. I wanna see more of her in the future because right now she's drawn most of my attention if not for Riorio.
3, Sakurako Wada - Not exactly the most prominent member, but she sticks out as the taller more bulkier member which is quite nice (strange to say). Got two solos though, that's a good thing to have lol.
4. Ayaka Hirose - Ahhh, she's got such strong vocals and I'm sure she'll do more once KF burns a little more gas and really show her leadership skills.
5. Ayano Hamaura - I think if she avoids hitting her squeaky notes, she'll go up my ranking because she sung quite confidently in "Survivor"
6. Minami Nomura - Surprised she's gotten such a push in recent times (having a solo in "Crying" to having a lot of solos in "Nen ni wa Nen", I feel like if she continues, she'll also go up my ranking.
7. Rena Ogawa - I loved Renako in her KSS days and I still do, but even I got to admit most of her groupmates are FAR better in the vocal department...maybe in due time.
8. Natsumi Taguchi - I really don't know why she's far down as she is, but she doesn't strike me in any way.
OVERALL: After their debut single, every member got a moment to shine, sadly they didn't really get PVs unlike the other groups so it was slightly more difficult to gauge where they stand with me (though the recording sessions for the songs are really cute!) 3/5
===Tsubaki Factory===
Though it's too early, I decided to do some preliminary thoughts
1. Riko Yamagishi - She's definitely my favorite of the bunch currently but mostly because of her role in Karen na Gasshoudan and the fact her rival is Minami Nomura...who's in Kobushi Factory hmmm
2. Yumeno Kishimoto - She's got a nice voice, I can say that...but the only thing I notice is her tan....
3. Kisora Niinuma - Squeaky voice is kind of eh, but she's grown out of it so I'll leave it like that.
4,5,6. Kiki Asakura, Ami Tanimoto, Risa Ogata - Essentially unknown to me right now...not much of an opinion on them, just wait and see what happens.
===Momusu===
1. Maria Makino - After seeing just the Another ver. of "Seishun Kozou ga Naiteiru", I figured she'd be the visual ace of the new generation. She seems the most polished and watching their dance shots, she looks like she has the most snap to her dancing which is a plus from being a KSS. Sadly, I really couldn't figure where she stands vocally amongst the other members.
2. Akane Haga - Maybe it's just me, but when I watch Akanechin...she exudes this serious demeanor and looks a lot more mature than maybe she knows herself. Like the other generation mates, vocally from the new single...they're all quite invisible and that's a shame.
3. Haruna Ogata - I blame "Ima Koko Kara" for this because I noticed Ogata quite a lot in that PV for some reason. Still, not sure where she'll fit, but she's quite nice to look at.
4. Miki Nonoka - Besides the multitude times I heard her speak English, if she didn't have that, I probably wouldn't have keyed in on her because I don't recall paying attention to her at all in any of the 4 PVs we got.
<b>OVERALL: </b>Visually, they were sticking out and I quickly recognized who was who...unfortunately, their debut single did nothing in terms of showing their vocal capabilities (since all they had were duet lines). 2/5
===ANGERME===
1. Mizuki Murota - Already in their debut single, Murotan is the vocal ace of the new generation. She's done quite a lot to get there and impressed many too. There's just something about her that works in the group and she honestly looks happy to perform with the group, so she's still one of my favorites!
2. Rikako Sasaki - I was surprised that Rikako and Maho got nothing in terms of lines in their debut single (whereas Murotan got two significant lines their debut). Howerver, Rikako is the visual ace it seems due to her popularity and because "Taikibansei" had her dead in the middle quite a lot. In time I bet she'll become one of the mains, but I think it's best left to Mizuki at the moment.
3. Maho Aikawa - I mean it wasn't very long for Aiai to debut and I was curious to how she sounded, but that didn't happen and she was a bit off in wherever she was (a little like Kanana when she started). I hope this awkward phase goes away because other than that, she's still kind of an unknown to me.
OVERALL: A little better than Momusu with showing off their members and having Murotan be the front vocals of the 3rd generation and Rikako as the visual representation...though where would Maho be then? lol. 3/5
===Country Girls===
1. Mai Ozeki - She is definitely my favorite of the group as of their first single. Something boyish about her is really pulling me in as well as her having my favorite color, blue. I do like her kind of raspy/husky voice to kind of counteract all the overall cuteness that the rest of the group has as well...she's just so charming!
2, Uta Shimomura - Which also is the same story as Utachan. She's REALLY charming as well and the fact that she's being pushed as the ace is quite surprising but effective, she's just a doll in "Itooshikutte Gomen ne".
3. Risa Yamaki - Even though she isn't the oldest thanks to Momoko, Yamakki is the odd member of the group I feel like. She's a lot more poised and mature and doesn't scream young girl which makes sense there...her voice is nice, a bit different against the other 5 members but refreshing I say.
4. Manaka Inaba - Besides the Dance Club stuff, Manakan's voice doesn't really do much for me (though that "Say! Hello!" line she has is pretty epic otherwise). Right now, she's kind of being shadowed by the rest of the group, so hopefully she catches up with me with adding her dance skills to the group.
5. Chisaki Morito - I really don't know why, but Chisaki just goes over my head and yet she gets more solo lines than Yamaki and Inaba :0 Made worse by the fact that Ozeki and Shimomura (and even Momoko) have such big charm points to them currently...I wanna see if she'll make a change by the end of the year.
OVERALL: Unlike Momusu and ANGERME, all the members got quite a lot of spotlight and solos and while they're on the rough side vocal-wise, their presence is quite worth it and Momoko doesn't get in the way 4/5
===Kobushi Factory===
1. Rio Fujii - With so much personality right from day 1, Rio has always been the underdog KSS for me and I'm so happy she was chosen as sub-leader of the group. While she isn't a vocal lead like Rei, Ayaka, and Minami...she's a great dancer so I'm definitely keeping my eye out for her.
2. Rei Inoue - When they first announced the group, I had no idea what to expect from Reirei but she's got some power in her voice. I wanna see more of her in the future because right now she's drawn most of my attention if not for Riorio.
3, Sakurako Wada - Not exactly the most prominent member, but she sticks out as the taller more bulkier member which is quite nice (strange to say). Got two solos though, that's a good thing to have lol.
4. Ayaka Hirose - Ahhh, she's got such strong vocals and I'm sure she'll do more once KF burns a little more gas and really show her leadership skills.
5. Ayano Hamaura - I think if she avoids hitting her squeaky notes, she'll go up my ranking because she sung quite confidently in "Survivor"
6. Minami Nomura - Surprised she's gotten such a push in recent times (having a solo in "Crying" to having a lot of solos in "Nen ni wa Nen", I feel like if she continues, she'll also go up my ranking.
7. Rena Ogawa - I loved Renako in her KSS days and I still do, but even I got to admit most of her groupmates are FAR better in the vocal department...maybe in due time.
8. Natsumi Taguchi - I really don't know why she's far down as she is, but she doesn't strike me in any way.
OVERALL: After their debut single, every member got a moment to shine, sadly they didn't really get PVs unlike the other groups so it was slightly more difficult to gauge where they stand with me (though the recording sessions for the songs are really cute!) 3/5
===Tsubaki Factory===
Though it's too early, I decided to do some preliminary thoughts
1. Riko Yamagishi - She's definitely my favorite of the bunch currently but mostly because of her role in Karen na Gasshoudan and the fact her rival is Minami Nomura...who's in Kobushi Factory hmmm
2. Yumeno Kishimoto - She's got a nice voice, I can say that...but the only thing I notice is her tan....
3. Kisora Niinuma - Squeaky voice is kind of eh, but she's grown out of it so I'll leave it like that.
4,5,6. Kiki Asakura, Ami Tanimoto, Risa Ogata - Essentially unknown to me right now...not much of an opinion on them, just wait and see what happens.
- TicTacAnyone
- ANGERME
- Posts: 2519
- Joined: Mon Jan 13, 2014 4:38 am
Re: Hello! Project Members Ranking ~2015 edition~
[quote="TicTacAnyone"]
"Love"
1. Suzuki Kanon
2. Suzuki Airi
3. Sugaya Risako
4. Nakajima Saki
5. Oda Sakura
6. Fukumura Mizuki
7. IIkubo Haruna
8. Kanazawa Tomoko
9. Ishida Ayumi
10. Nonaka Miki
"Really like"
11. Maa-chan
12. Ogata Haruna
13. Sayashi Riho
14. Takagi Sayuki
15. Shimamura Uta
16. Yajima Maimi
17. Tamura Meimi
18. Haga Akane
19. Inaba Manaka
20. Katsuta Rina
"Reallllly dislike"
40. Wada Ayaka (fluke)
41. Fukuda Kanon
42. Takeuchi Akari
43. Kumai Yurina
44. Sudou Maasa
45. Mitsui Aika
Since the middle rankings were "so-so/like" I just left them out since it's not as interesting, lol.
[/quote]
So, with Berryz gone, Country Girls getting their major debut/first single, 3rd gen Angerme getting settled in and the factories being added (also because I saw Thea posting about the sorter on Tumblr ;3) I decided to re-sort the girls.... And wow did it change hahaha
"Love"
1. Nonaka Miki
2. Suzuki Airi
3. Ishida Ayumi
4. Satou Masaki
5. Oda Sakura
6. Iikubo Haruna
7. Kanazawa Tomoko
8. Nakajima Saki
9. Murota Mizuki
10. Kudo Haruka
"Really like"
11. Hagiawara Mai
12. Suzuki Kanon
13. Wada Ayaka
14. Miyamoto Karin
15. Tamura Meimi
16. Takagi Sayuki
17. Sayashi Riho
18. Makino Maria
19. Uemura Akari
20. Fukumura Mizuki
The bottom was all the new girls, really, plus Fukuda Kanon, Mitsui Aika, and Eripon >.<
"Love"
1. Suzuki Kanon
2. Suzuki Airi
3. Sugaya Risako
4. Nakajima Saki
5. Oda Sakura
6. Fukumura Mizuki
7. IIkubo Haruna
8. Kanazawa Tomoko
9. Ishida Ayumi
10. Nonaka Miki
"Really like"
11. Maa-chan
12. Ogata Haruna
13. Sayashi Riho
14. Takagi Sayuki
15. Shimamura Uta
16. Yajima Maimi
17. Tamura Meimi
18. Haga Akane
19. Inaba Manaka
20. Katsuta Rina
"Reallllly dislike"
40. Wada Ayaka (fluke)
41. Fukuda Kanon
42. Takeuchi Akari
43. Kumai Yurina
44. Sudou Maasa
45. Mitsui Aika
Since the middle rankings were "so-so/like" I just left them out since it's not as interesting, lol.
[/quote]
So, with Berryz gone, Country Girls getting their major debut/first single, 3rd gen Angerme getting settled in and the factories being added (also because I saw Thea posting about the sorter on Tumblr ;3) I decided to re-sort the girls.... And wow did it change hahaha
"Love"
1. Nonaka Miki
2. Suzuki Airi
3. Ishida Ayumi
4. Satou Masaki
5. Oda Sakura
6. Iikubo Haruna
7. Kanazawa Tomoko
8. Nakajima Saki
9. Murota Mizuki
10. Kudo Haruka
"Really like"
11. Hagiawara Mai
12. Suzuki Kanon
13. Wada Ayaka
14. Miyamoto Karin
15. Tamura Meimi
16. Takagi Sayuki
17. Sayashi Riho
18. Makino Maria
19. Uemura Akari
20. Fukumura Mizuki
The bottom was all the new girls, really, plus Fukuda Kanon, Mitsui Aika, and Eripon >.<
- Solarblade
- ANGERME
- Posts: 1507
- Joined: Wed May 02, 2012 6:06 pm
Re: Hello! Project Members Ranking ~2015 edition~
So I thought I'd do another one after the 2nd wave of releases went through with the new girls.
===Momusu===
1. Nonaka - I think she's vocally the most stable and it shows when they were showing vocals off. She's kind of reminded me of Kame a little bit, I hope she goes in that direction because she's got quite a lot of potential (plus her additional English skills is being used nicely!).
2. Haga - After watching the GRADATION DVD, Haga has really nice vocals for someone so young, it's just unfortunate they haven't really utilized it quite yet besides a spoken dialogue in Oh my wish!. She'll become something special in the future I can bet on it!
3. Makino - She's decent, but she's already straining her vocals and that slightly worries me. She's kind of in the middle and she can be manipulated to go anywhere as a vocalist I think,
4. Ogata - She's definitely a poor vocalist right now, but I think there's some potential after TRIANGLE...just needs time!
Overall: The new girls did better on their 2nd single mostly and TRIANGLE and the GRADATION tour did better for some over others too. I'd say they're still kind of working their way into the group as they still didn't have a HUGE role in the single (Akane and Haruna had spoken dialogue in Oh my wish! and Miki and Maria had lines in Ima Sugu Tobikomu Yuuki) so mostly this came down to their Suki na Senpai performance.
==ANGERME==
1. Murota
2. Sasaki
3. Aikawa
Overall: I think the 2nd single did better for 3rd Gen to step out into the light as we get our first official solo lines to Rikako and Maho. Though the standings remained the same for me as Mizuki is still a powerhouse and Sasaki as the new face/blood. Luckily, Aiai has managed to get better with her solo lines and she has a cute lisp to her that surprised me more than I expected. Even though I feel like this is how it'll be for the 3rd single, I do love these girls!
===Country Girls===
1. Ozeki - I'm seriously loving her voice more and more and now with this tomboy act thrown in due to Wakatte Iru no ni Gomen ne, she's definitely my favorite within the group especially after Utachan left.
2. Inaba - She's just surprising me more and more, she can do such a cute girl act and then hit us with a bombastic dance performance, it boggles my mind if she was totally meant for Country Girls or Momusu to be honest...still Manakan is a great member for sure.
3. Morito - I think the fact she was shoved down our throats for Wakatte and somewhat Tamerai Summertime should say something for her at least. She still lacks some kind of standout personality at the moment, but since Uta's departure I think it did better for her in the long run.
4. Yamaki - Sadly the only member that really hasn't done much outside of the 2nd single, Yamaki is still a great member, but I think we need a single for her to make her fit in this group perfectly.
Overall: I know Uta leaving shook the group up (and seeing people dismiss the group purely for that fact is so silly and overdramatic as it is). I think the group managed to get Chisaki out there more while Dance Team pushed Manaka out as well...everyone else has kind of remained at the same level for me, but I'm sure there's more to come
===Kobushi===
1. Fujii - Like Ozeki, Fujii's kind of boyish looks caught my eyes and she's been a favorite of mine for a long time so this is kind of a no-brainer...plus her voice is really interesting especially in Dosukoi and Nen ni wa Nen.
2. Nomura - Likewise, Nomura has seriously been going up my charts since the group formed and I feel like she's the visual ace at the moment which is really cool to watch.
3. Hirose - Vocal powerhouse is great and Ayapan is just mesmerizing as a member...she looks so mature!
4. Inoue - Beyond the fact that she does the most of the 8 being a regular on Oha Star, Reirei is also someone I'm closely following as she's a surprising member with such a cool voice on her.
5. Ogawa - While I do think vocally, she's the weakest...her appearances make her look so elegant and poised and I'm loving that alongside she's the only one I think who pulls it off in an otherwise rockin' group!
6. Hamaura - Cute and she's got potential to let go of her squeaky vocals as we've seen from the single, but the 5 above her just strike me so much more.
7. Wada - Really the last two comes down to the fact they're kind of the back girls at the moment. Wada sticks out due to her height while Taguchi with how short so it's a bit bizarre that they're both at the bottom.
8. Taguchi
Overall: As their debut major single passes by, I feel like this group is going to go on to do amazing things. They all are members I really loved prior (with the exception of Inoue and Hirose). They all just gel together so well and with their genre of rock as their foundation...it's just a perfect mash right now!
===Tsubaki===
1. Kishimoto
2. Yamagishi
3. Asakura
4. Niinuma
5. Ogata
6. Tanimoto
Overall: Right now, this is how they're ranking right now. There's no one that really screams out favorite of the group by skill because 5 of the 6 girls are almost even on one another on how they are in the group. Tanimoto though has a LOT of work to go through, but she's just so darn adorable that she might just bypass on her personality alone. I'm sure with more releases this will broaden out more, but for right now it's just this.
===Momusu===
1. Nonaka - I think she's vocally the most stable and it shows when they were showing vocals off. She's kind of reminded me of Kame a little bit, I hope she goes in that direction because she's got quite a lot of potential (plus her additional English skills is being used nicely!).
2. Haga - After watching the GRADATION DVD, Haga has really nice vocals for someone so young, it's just unfortunate they haven't really utilized it quite yet besides a spoken dialogue in Oh my wish!. She'll become something special in the future I can bet on it!
3. Makino - She's decent, but she's already straining her vocals and that slightly worries me. She's kind of in the middle and she can be manipulated to go anywhere as a vocalist I think,
4. Ogata - She's definitely a poor vocalist right now, but I think there's some potential after TRIANGLE...just needs time!
Overall: The new girls did better on their 2nd single mostly and TRIANGLE and the GRADATION tour did better for some over others too. I'd say they're still kind of working their way into the group as they still didn't have a HUGE role in the single (Akane and Haruna had spoken dialogue in Oh my wish! and Miki and Maria had lines in Ima Sugu Tobikomu Yuuki) so mostly this came down to their Suki na Senpai performance.
==ANGERME==
1. Murota
2. Sasaki
3. Aikawa
Overall: I think the 2nd single did better for 3rd Gen to step out into the light as we get our first official solo lines to Rikako and Maho. Though the standings remained the same for me as Mizuki is still a powerhouse and Sasaki as the new face/blood. Luckily, Aiai has managed to get better with her solo lines and she has a cute lisp to her that surprised me more than I expected. Even though I feel like this is how it'll be for the 3rd single, I do love these girls!
===Country Girls===
1. Ozeki - I'm seriously loving her voice more and more and now with this tomboy act thrown in due to Wakatte Iru no ni Gomen ne, she's definitely my favorite within the group especially after Utachan left.
2. Inaba - She's just surprising me more and more, she can do such a cute girl act and then hit us with a bombastic dance performance, it boggles my mind if she was totally meant for Country Girls or Momusu to be honest...still Manakan is a great member for sure.
3. Morito - I think the fact she was shoved down our throats for Wakatte and somewhat Tamerai Summertime should say something for her at least. She still lacks some kind of standout personality at the moment, but since Uta's departure I think it did better for her in the long run.
4. Yamaki - Sadly the only member that really hasn't done much outside of the 2nd single, Yamaki is still a great member, but I think we need a single for her to make her fit in this group perfectly.
Overall: I know Uta leaving shook the group up (and seeing people dismiss the group purely for that fact is so silly and overdramatic as it is). I think the group managed to get Chisaki out there more while Dance Team pushed Manaka out as well...everyone else has kind of remained at the same level for me, but I'm sure there's more to come
===Kobushi===
1. Fujii - Like Ozeki, Fujii's kind of boyish looks caught my eyes and she's been a favorite of mine for a long time so this is kind of a no-brainer...plus her voice is really interesting especially in Dosukoi and Nen ni wa Nen.
2. Nomura - Likewise, Nomura has seriously been going up my charts since the group formed and I feel like she's the visual ace at the moment which is really cool to watch.
3. Hirose - Vocal powerhouse is great and Ayapan is just mesmerizing as a member...she looks so mature!
4. Inoue - Beyond the fact that she does the most of the 8 being a regular on Oha Star, Reirei is also someone I'm closely following as she's a surprising member with such a cool voice on her.
5. Ogawa - While I do think vocally, she's the weakest...her appearances make her look so elegant and poised and I'm loving that alongside she's the only one I think who pulls it off in an otherwise rockin' group!
6. Hamaura - Cute and she's got potential to let go of her squeaky vocals as we've seen from the single, but the 5 above her just strike me so much more.
7. Wada - Really the last two comes down to the fact they're kind of the back girls at the moment. Wada sticks out due to her height while Taguchi with how short so it's a bit bizarre that they're both at the bottom.
8. Taguchi
Overall: As their debut major single passes by, I feel like this group is going to go on to do amazing things. They all are members I really loved prior (with the exception of Inoue and Hirose). They all just gel together so well and with their genre of rock as their foundation...it's just a perfect mash right now!
===Tsubaki===
1. Kishimoto
2. Yamagishi
3. Asakura
4. Niinuma
5. Ogata
6. Tanimoto
Overall: Right now, this is how they're ranking right now. There's no one that really screams out favorite of the group by skill because 5 of the 6 girls are almost even on one another on how they are in the group. Tanimoto though has a LOT of work to go through, but she's just so darn adorable that she might just bypass on her personality alone. I'm sure with more releases this will broaden out more, but for right now it's just this.
Re: Hello! Project Members Ranking ~2015 edition~
I'm lazy. Or am I not lazy? This took time, but then again, not really. xD
I did my mid-year ranking as well. But Tsubaki Factory, ugh. I'm TRYING REALLY HARD with them. But they are just all so, horrible at singing. Praying for a miracle.
Anyone after 20 was basically just thrown there. Aside from Mai, Rina, Chisaki, Akari, Erina and Maria who are naturally in the bottom of their respective groups. Kobushi Factory I have no clear order for them yet. So that's probably the only groups that will really make a big shift by next year for sure.
C-ute, and Juice=Juice are the only permanently stable ranking groups. Country Girls, while they are a clear ranking, the top three change on any given day, but I have a clear favorite.
C-ute - Airi, Chisato, Maimi, Saki and Mai
Juice=Juice - Sayuki, Karin, Tomoko, Yuka and Akari
Country Girls - Risa, Manaka, O.Mai. <- Varies though Risa is winning the #1 spot left by Uta. I still miss Uta. T______T
Momoko and Chisaki
Morning Musume - Sakura, Zukki.
Varies -> Haruka, Masaki (She'll stay up here as long as she continues to use her big girl voice), Riho, Miki, Mizuki, Haruna, Akane, Ayumi, O.Haruna, Erina, Maria
ANGERME - Meimi, Mizuki, Kanon.
Varies -> Kana, Akari, Maho, Rikako, Ayaka, Rina
Kana may take over Kanon's spot. I LIKE Rikako, I just need her to mature a bit more before I can put her any higher. Maho's spot isn't secure, she's too green. I'm enjoying her blog more than anything. Akari, while great, just doesn't have enough spark for me to keep her in a stable spot. Ayaka is filler, she should probably be higher but vocally, Kana and Akari are more my taste. Rikako and Maho just beat her out for their newness. Rina is stuck at the bottom, honestly I probably should have put her above C-ute's Mai, but I think I was having a bitter moment the day I did the poll. xD
Kobushi Factory, I'm not even really there yet to place them properly. Though I do like all the girls in Kobushi, I can name a few of them off the top of my head easily. But I have a trouble with a few others. Once I can get them all, I'll be able to rank them properly.
I did my mid-year ranking as well. But Tsubaki Factory, ugh. I'm TRYING REALLY HARD with them. But they are just all so, horrible at singing. Praying for a miracle.
Anyone after 20 was basically just thrown there. Aside from Mai, Rina, Chisaki, Akari, Erina and Maria who are naturally in the bottom of their respective groups. Kobushi Factory I have no clear order for them yet. So that's probably the only groups that will really make a big shift by next year for sure.
C-ute, and Juice=Juice are the only permanently stable ranking groups. Country Girls, while they are a clear ranking, the top three change on any given day, but I have a clear favorite.
C-ute - Airi, Chisato, Maimi, Saki and Mai
Juice=Juice - Sayuki, Karin, Tomoko, Yuka and Akari
Country Girls - Risa, Manaka, O.Mai. <- Varies though Risa is winning the #1 spot left by Uta. I still miss Uta. T______T
Momoko and Chisaki
Morning Musume - Sakura, Zukki.
Varies -> Haruka, Masaki (She'll stay up here as long as she continues to use her big girl voice), Riho, Miki, Mizuki, Haruna, Akane, Ayumi, O.Haruna, Erina, Maria
ANGERME - Meimi, Mizuki, Kanon.
Varies -> Kana, Akari, Maho, Rikako, Ayaka, Rina
Kana may take over Kanon's spot. I LIKE Rikako, I just need her to mature a bit more before I can put her any higher. Maho's spot isn't secure, she's too green. I'm enjoying her blog more than anything. Akari, while great, just doesn't have enough spark for me to keep her in a stable spot. Ayaka is filler, she should probably be higher but vocally, Kana and Akari are more my taste. Rikako and Maho just beat her out for their newness. Rina is stuck at the bottom, honestly I probably should have put her above C-ute's Mai, but I think I was having a bitter moment the day I did the poll. xD
Kobushi Factory, I'm not even really there yet to place them properly. Though I do like all the girls in Kobushi, I can name a few of them off the top of my head easily. But I have a trouble with a few others. Once I can get them all, I'll be able to rank them properly.
Last edited by Shoujo Q on Sun Sep 20, 2015 9:39 am, edited 1 time in total.
This is a place where a signature goes. Enjoy some Airi instead.
Re: Hello! Project Members Ranking ~2015 edition~
^ Where did you find the ranker for all of H!P. More specifically, what's the url?
Formerly Mizura
Re: Hello! Project Members Ranking ~2015 edition~
It's on the first page of this thread. But here's the link for you. http://www.geocities.jp/gzonegsp/sort/mergesort.html
They also have one for Past and present Morning Musume too.
They also have one for Past and present Morning Musume too.
This is a place where a signature goes. Enjoy some Airi instead.
Re: Hello! Project Members Ranking ~2015 edition~
Today I learned that Geocities is still a thing in some parts of the world.
Jpope On Jpop! blog
Re: Hello! Project Members Ranking ~2015 edition~
I did the sort and this was the ranking I got for it.
- Okai Chisato
- Suzuki Airi
- Suzuki Kanon
- Oda Sakura
- Ishida Ayumi
- Nakanishi Kana
- Fujii Rio
- Sayashi Riho
- Kudo Haruka
- Takagi Sayuki
- Uemura Akari
- Yamaki Risa
- Iikubo Haruna
- Taguchi Natsumi
- Morito Chisaki
- Sato Masaki
- Murota Mizuki
- Ogata Haruna
- Inoue Rei
- Nomura Minami
- Inaba Manaka
- Katsuta Rina
- Hirose Ayaka
- Tsugunaga Momoko
- Wada Ayaka
- Haga Akane
- Nonaka Miki
- Hamura Ayano
- Ikuta Erina
- Hagiwara Mai
- Sasaki Rikako
- Fukumura Mizuki
- Kanazawa Tomoko
- Yajima Maimi
- Nakajima Saki
- Ozeki Mai
- Takeuchi Akari
- Tamura Meimi
- Miyazaki Yuka
- Fukuda Kanon
- Wada Sakurako
- Ogawa Rena
- Aikawa Maho
- Makino Maria
- Miyamoto Karin
- Kishimoto Yumeno
- Yamagaishi Riko
- Ogata Risa
- Niinuma Kisora
- Mitsui Aika
- Tanimoto Ami
- Asakura Kiki
Formerly Mizura
Re: Hello! Project Members Ranking ~2015 edition~
I recently re-did the sort as well, and since I know Kobushi better now I think it's worth posting.
Just MM:
<div> </div>
<div>01 (01) Sayashi Riho</div>
<div>02 (02) Kudou Haruka </div>
<div>03 (04) Haga Akane </div>
<div>04 (08) Ishida Ayumi </div>
<div>05 (12) Oda Sakura </div>
<div>06 (14) Iikubo Haruna </div>
<div>07 (18) Ogata Haruna </div>
<div>08 (21) Fukumura Mizuki </div>
<div>09 (24) Ikuta Erina </div>
<div>10 (24) Suzuki Kanon </div>
<div>11 (30) Nonaka Miki </div>
<div>12 (42) Satou Masaki </div>
<div>13 (42) Makino Maria</div>
H!P under the spoiler.
<div></div>
</div>
Just MM:
<div> </div>
<div>01 (01) Sayashi Riho</div>
<div>02 (02) Kudou Haruka </div>
<div>03 (04) Haga Akane </div>
<div>04 (08) Ishida Ayumi </div>
<div>05 (12) Oda Sakura </div>
<div>06 (14) Iikubo Haruna </div>
<div>07 (18) Ogata Haruna </div>
<div>08 (21) Fukumura Mizuki </div>
<div>09 (24) Ikuta Erina </div>
<div>10 (24) Suzuki Kanon </div>
<div>11 (30) Nonaka Miki </div>
<div>12 (42) Satou Masaki </div>
<div>13 (42) Makino Maria</div>
H!P under the spoiler.
<div></div>
</div>
Re: Hello! Project Members Ranking ~2015 edition~
1位
Oda Sakura
153p
2位
Nakanishi Kana
150p
3位
Takagi Sayuki
147p
4位
Hagiwara Mai
144p
5位
Suzuki Kanon
141p
6位
Kanazawa Tomoko
138p
7位
Yajima Maimi
135p
8位
Tamura Meimi
132p
9位
Ogata Haruna
129p
10位
Murota Mizuki
126p
11位
Sasaki Rikako
123p
12位
Ikuta Erina
120p
13位
Hamaura Ayano
117p
14位
Ishida Ayumi
114p
15位
Wada Ayaka
111p
16位
Hirose Ayaka
108p
17位
Inaba Manaka
105p
18位
Ogawa Rena
102p
19位
Kudou Haruka
99p
20位
Nonaka Miki
96p
21位
Inoue Rei
93p
22位
Suzuki Airi
90p
23位
Uemura Akari
87p
24位
Nakajima Saki
84p
25位
Fukumura Mizuki
81p
26位
Iikubo Haruna
78p
27位
Sayashi Riho
75p
28位
Miyamoto Karin
72p
29位
Makino Maria
69p
30位
Taguchi Natsumi
66p
31位
Aikawa Maho
63p
32位
Nomura Minami
60p
33位
Fukuda Kanon
57p
34位
Morita Chisaki
54p
35位
Haga Akane
51p
36位
Fujii Rio
48p
37位
Yamaki Risa
45p
38位
Wada Sakurako
42p
39位
Ozeki Mai
39p
40位
Kishimoto Yumeno
36p
41位
Yamagishi Riko
33p
42位
Niinuma Kisora
30p
43位
Asakura Kiki
27p
44位
Takeuchi Akari
24p
45位
Ogata Risa
21p
46位
Tanimoto Ami
18p
47位
Miyazaki Yuka
15p
48位
Tsugunaga Momoko
12p
49位
Katsuta Rina
9p
50位
Okai Chisato
6p
51位
Satou Masaki
3p
52位
Mitsui Aika
0p
OK so the top ten is mostly right. There are some things that seem odd, like I definitely like Rena more than Ayaka within Kobushi, and Rei should not rank higher than Airi. But yeah, like everyone else said...Tsubaki just basically doesn't rank for me at all yet. The only people lower than them are my forever bottom six.
Also I have no idea when Dawa jumped up that high.
Oda Sakura
153p
2位
Nakanishi Kana
150p
3位
Takagi Sayuki
147p
4位
Hagiwara Mai
144p
5位
Suzuki Kanon
141p
6位
Kanazawa Tomoko
138p
7位
Yajima Maimi
135p
8位
Tamura Meimi
132p
9位
Ogata Haruna
129p
10位
Murota Mizuki
126p
11位
Sasaki Rikako
123p
12位
Ikuta Erina
120p
13位
Hamaura Ayano
117p
14位
Ishida Ayumi
114p
15位
Wada Ayaka
111p
16位
Hirose Ayaka
108p
17位
Inaba Manaka
105p
18位
Ogawa Rena
102p
19位
Kudou Haruka
99p
20位
Nonaka Miki
96p
21位
Inoue Rei
93p
22位
Suzuki Airi
90p
23位
Uemura Akari
87p
24位
Nakajima Saki
84p
25位
Fukumura Mizuki
81p
26位
Iikubo Haruna
78p
27位
Sayashi Riho
75p
28位
Miyamoto Karin
72p
29位
Makino Maria
69p
30位
Taguchi Natsumi
66p
31位
Aikawa Maho
63p
32位
Nomura Minami
60p
33位
Fukuda Kanon
57p
34位
Morita Chisaki
54p
35位
Haga Akane
51p
36位
Fujii Rio
48p
37位
Yamaki Risa
45p
38位
Wada Sakurako
42p
39位
Ozeki Mai
39p
40位
Kishimoto Yumeno
36p
41位
Yamagishi Riko
33p
42位
Niinuma Kisora
30p
43位
Asakura Kiki
27p
44位
Takeuchi Akari
24p
45位
Ogata Risa
21p
46位
Tanimoto Ami
18p
47位
Miyazaki Yuka
15p
48位
Tsugunaga Momoko
12p
49位
Katsuta Rina
9p
50位
Okai Chisato
6p
51位
Satou Masaki
3p
52位
Mitsui Aika
0p
OK so the top ten is mostly right. There are some things that seem odd, like I definitely like Rena more than Ayaka within Kobushi, and Rei should not rank higher than Airi. But yeah, like everyone else said...Tsubaki just basically doesn't rank for me at all yet. The only people lower than them are my forever bottom six.
Also I have no idea when Dawa jumped up that high.
♥ Kaori • Risako ♥
♥ Sakura • Kananan • Sayuki ♥
- arcobaleno
- ANGERME
- Posts: 2269
- Joined: Fri Jul 12, 2013 12:13 pm
Re: Hello! Project Members Ranking ~2015 edition~
Since this is always my favorite bandwagon to jump on, I did a fresh one just a few minutes ago.
By Group:
All H!P: </div>
<div> </div>
<div>No issues with mine, I'd say, in terms of someone being higher than the other when they really aren't.</div>
By Group:
All H!P: </div>
<div> </div>
<div>No issues with mine, I'd say, in terms of someone being higher than the other when they really aren't.</div>
Last edited by arcobaleno on Mon Sep 21, 2015 10:42 am, edited 1 time in total.
●✿✿✿✿✿●